3 stars (9)
- Americana Motel Tucumcari
- Best Western Discovery Inn Tucumcari
- Days Inn By Wyndham Tucumcari
- Desert Inn Tucumcari
- Fairfield Inn & Suites By Marriott Tucumcari
- Hampton Inn Tucumcari Nm
- La Quinta By Wyndham Tucumcari Hotel
- Pow Wow Inn Tucumcari
- Tristar Inn Xpress Tucumcari
2 stars (11)
- Almara Inn Tucumcari
- Budget Inn Tucumcari
- Econo Lodge Tucumcari Route 66 - I-40
- Holiday Inn Express And Suites - Tucumcari, An Ihg Hotel
- Motel 6-Tucumcari, Nm
- Quality Inn Tucumcari
- Roadrunner Lodge Motel Tucumcari
- Rodeway Inn Tucumcari
- Sunset Inn Tucumcari Nm
- Super 8 By Wyndham Tucumcari Hotel
- Tucumcari Travelodge